Disconnect
What happens when property prices on investment property are not supported by rental rates? You’d think it would mean one (or more) of several things:
Rents would be forced up to provide a decent return on property prices;
Property prices would decrease so that market rents provide a decent return;
Properties that are overpriced will not sell.
Well, welcome to the boom. As you might have guess, there’s more here than meets the eye because none of the above seems to be happening in Fredericksburg, TX. Logic has taken a back seat to speculation and greed. This is dangerous territory we’re getting in to.
A boom market is a little like a game of musical chairs. Someone is going to be left standing when the music stops. If you are eying an investment property (i.e. one you’re going to buy and not live in) you look for several things; potential rental income, potential out of pocket costs (repairs upkeep, taxes, etc.), mortgage rates (unless you can pay cash—more about this later), appreciation and location, location, location. The idea is to generate a cash-on-cash return that is greater than another investment alternative (i.e. stocks, etc.). If you can’t, you shouldn’t be buying. In this market, the only thing that makes people take the plunge is the potential for appreciation.
Appreciation is the great unknown. Again, it’s like musical chairs. Do you really want to be the one left standing? People are growing accustom to carrying a negative cash flow (i.e. rents don’t pay the mortgage, insurance and taxes) with the assumption that the property will net them enough money when they sell it to make a substantial return, despite the negative carry.
Here’s the part that may cause a stir. Rents have got to increase. All you landlords out there need to realize that there is a serious disconnect between property values, rents and returns. There is also a growing shortage of quality rental product. Put this all together and it spells RENT INCREASES! The alternative is for sellers to lower their prices…that isn’t going to happen with mortgage rates hovering near historic lows.
Real estate can still generate serious returns (as compared to other investments), especially if you have the ability to pay cash. Do away with the 6% of interest you have to pay on a mortgage and suddenly your negative cash flow becomes positive. Compare an 8% (before tax) return on a “safe” investment like real estate to you other investments and it might give you pause.
Paying cash is counter-intuitive to the notion of leverage, but we live in strange times.
